Do Republicans and Democrats who hold jobs with poor working conditions have similar views on pro-union labor policy? Extensive research in American political behavior counsels against such an expectation, as a long line of research suggests individuals absorb the views of their party and therefore Republicans and Democrats should hold vastly different views on labor policy. However, this underestimates the potentially meaningful role of personal experience in policy preferences as a potential counterweight to partisanship. A key limitation to testing this has been the absence of data with workers’ preferences and direct measures of working conditions. This study draws on original data on 5,425 service sector workers to examine the relationship between partisanship, direct experience with poor working conditions, and labor policy preferences. The results suggest that partisanship is an important determinant of labor policy preferences, but only when workers work in relatively good jobs. Among workers with good working conditions, partisanship is influential and Republicans and Democrats hold significantly different views on labor policy. Yet as working conditions deteriorate, the role of partisanship diminishes and Republican and Democratic workers’ views converge and align, with both embracing pro-union labor policy preferences.
Recommended Citation
Gregory Lyon, Daniel Schneider, Direct Experience with Poor Working Conditions and Partisan Labor Policy Preferences, Public Opinion Quarterly, 2025; nfaf048, https://doi.org/10.1093/poq/nfaf048
Press Coverage
Amazon promises ‘big deals’ — but not for delivery workers
Senators pressure Jeff Bezos over Amazon schedules they say squeeze workers
She went viral running a Burger King solo. Then she got fired.
The California Job-Killer That Wasn’t
New study shows impact of $20/hr for fast food workers
Sam’s Club will raise pay to catch up with Costco
Are “bad jobs” dead ends or steppingstones to better things?
Front-line employees don’t envy remote workers, Gallup data shows
Unstable scheduling harmful for worker health: Fair workweek laws gain steam
How to get flexible working right
The Catch-22 for Working Parents
Fair Workweek Act furthest thing from radical
America Needs To Improve How It Treats Its Older Workers
Why Schedule Sanity is Workers’ New Fight for $15
Dynamic Scheduling Fails Companies and Workers
Stop calling paid leave a ‘quality of life’ issue. It’s a basic need
NJ Family Leave Insurance: Even hourly workers are eligible
Editorial: Give fast-food workers some say on the job
If the Job Market Is So Good, Why Is Gig Work Thriving?
California could transform how fast food workers are treated
Americans need to get better at taking sick days
Why Economic Justice Begins In The Food Industry
Corporations Won’t Pay $15 an Hour Unless They’re Forced To
Life in the Real Economy
Give Service Workers Stable Schedules
Connecticut workers deserve predictable hours
A Key to Returning to Normal Is Paid Sick Leave, Democrats Say
Service workers still struggle with unstable schedules
Despite Labor Shortages, Workers See Few Gains in Economic Security
Minority Shift Workers More Likely to Face Unstable Schedules
Americans are showing up sick to work even as Omicron spreads
Exposing the Precarious Nature of California’s Service Sector
The Real Reason Americans Aren’t Isolating.
Omicron Is Making America’s Bad Jobs Even Worse
Red Lobster workers say they’re forced to work sick through pandemic
Amazon requires masks again at all U.S. warehouses.
Whiplash on U.S. Vaccine Mandate Leaves Employers ‘Totally Confused’
Stay home or work sick? Omicron poses a conundrum
Red Lobster workers say they are forced to work sick
CVS and Walgreens just cut down paid sick leave for workers
How a law on shift scheduling helps many women workers in Seattle
Workers fed up with nights, weekends seek flexible schedules
A sociologist discusses the so-called “Great Resignation”
Shift Scheduling Laws Can Boost Worker Well Being
Long hours make bad neighbors
The “Essential Worker” Swindle
Workers At These Companies Say They’re Still Not Safe From COVID-19
End of $600 unemployment boost pushes more households to the edge
Floridians Fared Worst in Study of Pandemic Unemployment Relief
Unemployed faced major barriers to financial support
American Retail Workers Face a New Racial Gap
Essential workers should be treated with more respect
Opinion: Sephora Never Valued Workers Like Me
Elizabeth Warren Has a Plan to Protect Essential Workers
Without Sick Leave, Workers Put Customers at Risk
Walmart’s Emergency Sick Leave Is Not Good Enough
The U.S. Is Shutting Down. For Walmart, It’s Time to Step Up
Workers At These Companies Say They Can’t Get Sick Leave
The Companies Putting Profits Ahead of Public Health
Here’s What Happens When an Algorithm Determines Your Work Schedule
Washington State lawmakers push for secure scheduling legislation
New Jersey lawmakers consider secure scheduling bill
Elizabeth Warren Wants To Help Workers With Unpredictable Schedules
White House hopeful Warren takes aim at unpredictable work schedules
Warren and Schakowsky Unveil Part-Time Workers Bill of Rights
The movement to make workers’ schedules more humane
Labor’s next $15 minimum wage: Fair scheduling for shift workers
Coalition Pushes for Fairness in Work Schedules
How Unpredictable Work Hours Turn Families Upside Down
The brutal psychological toll of erratic work schedules
Poor scheduling costs hourly workers sleep and happiness
For job quality, time is more than money
Black Friday Isn’t the Only Time Workers Face Unfair Schedules
Boosting Workers’ Hours May Be Solution to Holiday Hiring Woes
Desperate for labor, retailers offer workers more hours
Predictable Shift Laws Spread to More Cities, States
New Laws Aim to Make Work Hours More Predictable
Living Paycheck to Paycheck, and Hour to Hour
Daniel Schneider selected as a 2018 William T. Grant Scholar
More Families Feel Insecure. That’s Because They Are.
Harknett presents to Philadelphia City Council
How unpredictable schedules hurt Philly service workers
Working in the Service Sector in Philadelphia – New Research Brief